by Marylaine Block
I've had reason lately to do research in popular culture. I recently wrote a tribute to Charles Schulz and Peanuts (#foxnews.com/fn99/views/block/052300.sml). I've also just signed a contract with Information Today to edit a book of the wit and wisdom of Barbara Quint, and my publisher suggested I should get ahold of similar sorts of books, like, for instance, The Wit and Wisdom of Archie Bunker.
As I tried to find copies of Peanuts anthologies and the Archie Bunker book, I was reminded anew how few libraries retain this kind of material, if they ever bought it in the first place.
Mind you, as one whose library was drastically overcrowded, I understand why librarians don't feel they CAN retain things that date so rapidly, or rarely circulate, or are inherently trivial. When our space is limited, we really do have to concentrate on our core collection.
At the same time, trivial as some of these things are, they are important as carriers of cultural values and knowledge.
What library, for instance, would make a point of keeping every Harlequin romance? And yet over the years they rather accurately trace the changes in sexual mores, women's views of romance, and ideas about the roles of men and women. (Men's changing ideas about sex and relationships can be traced just as accurately through long runs of men's magazines.) Here's an interesting research question: at what point did most romances stop ending with a kiss and a promise of marriage, and end instead with marriage AFTER passionate sex?
Relatively few libraries collect and keep books of political cartoons, presumably because they become dated so quickly. And yet what better way to trace political history? Because cartoonists only make jokes about things they expect people to understand, they are a gauge of what was commonly understood at any given period. One fetching cartoon book from 1992, called The Cat Who Would Be President (held by few libraries), is a wonderful parody of Clinton's campaign, complete with scandals and feeble defenses.
How many libraries keep old Penney's and Sears' catalogs? Yet they are invaluable guides to how people lived, what they coveted, and what they could reasonably afford at any given time. They're a gold mine of information for theatrical costumers and set designers.
That's the same reason I will be sorry if libraries throw away their archived magazines under the theory that the full text is available online. The full text of the articles may be, but what are you losing? For one thing, the cartoons. In the middle of a Barbara Quint article in Wilson Library Bulletin there was a cartoon showing a male genie coming out of a bottle, saying "I am the genie of tech support, and I will grant you three wishes." Is that cultural zeitgeist or what?
You also lose the ads, again a great source of information on how people live and dress, and what they covet. You lose the letters to the editor, the authentic voices of ordinary people talking back. Maybe the letters will be preserved in other forms, as when Ms published a book of letters to Ms., but then again, maybe not. You would lose the jokes, too -- the filler material like the snide cracks in the New Yorker, or Mary Ann Madden's competitions in New York Magazine or the weird and wonderful real newspaper goofs in Columbia Journalism Review's "Lower Case" (PROSTATE CANCER MORE COMMON IN MEN).
I wish we could organize ourselves so that we'd each keep a small chunk of that history told in ephemera. Maybe one library could collect all the Harlequin novels by authors whose names start with A, another library the Bs, and so on; other libraries then, could send their discards to the appropriate library, making sure that that bit of history doesn't vanish. Other libraries could cooperate to save cartoon books, or children's books.
Maybe it's a pipe dream, and maybe it's just too much trouble for understaffed libraries and overburdened librarians. Maybe we can just put our faith in the Library of Congress and in places like Bowling Green State University's popular culture library, that deliberately collect comic books, genre fiction, Nancy Drew books, pulp magazines, and Star Trek memorabilia.
But before we throw stuff like this away, we could at least give it a chance to live again by displaying it, and letting people see this little chunk of our past.
Copyright, Marylaine Block, 2000.
Worth: an occasional column by
Ex Libris An E-Zine for Librarians and other Information Junkies
About Marylaine Block